Blog #3
Blog #3
Hi everyone! Hope you enjoy my blog this week!

- Select 1 of the Topics/Compelling Questions you and your partner worked through for the Foundational Elements assignment and share it here. Be sure to include all elements (basically copy and paste): Standards, Bundle Defense, Compelling Question, Compelling Question Defense.
My standards:
Topic: K-2nd wants and needs
D2.Eco.1.K-2. Explain how scarcity necessitates decision making.
Theme #1 Culture: Explore and describe similarities and differences in the ways various cultural groups meet similar needs and concerns (Page 28).
Bundle Defense: I believe these two themes compliment each other well for the topic of wants and needs for young learners. This is because when it comes to economic decision making during a scarcity of resources culture has a big impact. That led me to find a great culture standard that dives into why cultures make decisions for their societies. This means not only will we learn how more than one group makes a decision during tough times we will know how their cultural values affected said decision.
Compelling Question: The Native Americans followed the buffalo migration. The settlers of North America took the Oregon trail. What do these two groups have in common?
Question Defense: This question checks the boxes that make a compelling question for various reasons. To start this question is student friendly because the language is digestible for young readers. This question also engages young students to explore more than one reason why this statement may or may not be true. With no direct answer it opens up the investigation to deeper than surface level thinking on two different groups in history, and this in turn makes the question have more academic value. This question lastly is worthwhile for the students because they get to compare two things that may seem completely different. Then discover independently they may be similar in more ways than they could imagine.
- Then, push your thinking to the next set of steps. In your Blog, propose a set of supporting questions and use them to write up an answer to the compelling question that you think students would be able to achieve.
1. Why did the Native Americans follow the buffalos as they migrated?
2. What are some of the reasons that people took the risk of the Oregon trail?
One answer to my compelling question is that both groups saw a path that could lead to a better life for their communities and help with dwindling resources, so either risk was worth taking.
Hi Ryan,
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed reading about your question and why you chose the things you did. I thought your question was really strong because not only does offer an a opportunity to explore wants and needs, but students get to do that through comparing and contrasting different groups. This provides a space for many connections to be made. Nice work!
Ryan,
ReplyDeleteI like how you paired the theme with the dimension, it makes a lot of sense and also will provide your students with many possibilities when coming up with an answer to your compelling question, which I also thought was very thought-provoking and has a number of answers your students can give. You presented them with two reasons on the way the groups decided to go the way they did, and asked them to compare. Which is also supported by your supporting questions, so I like how those go along with the compelling question to keep your students on track. Your answer to the question also seems like an easy enough answer to come to when it comes to the age group you chose. Good job!
I enjoyed how you had students look at both sides of the movement and then look at specifics for each group. Natives and settlers both had trials and tribulations they went through and many reasons why they traveled this area. The way you broke it up made it easy to follow and think critically about all sides.
ReplyDelete